I loved Knit by Nora's posting about the "Celebrity Scarves" book, mostly because I feel the same way (don't we all love having our opinions validated?).
In reading this book, none of represented themselves as any thing other than novice knitters. The reasons many of these celebrities knit are the same as ordinary people, because of a woman in the family, to feel creative or for relaxation. Knocking novice knitters, even “celebrities” is easy to do and just a bit arrogant.
So many bloggers have made fun of the "celebrity knitting" thing, Darryl Hannah, etc. I'm not a celebrity (except in my own mind), but I have a lot of the same attitudes toward knitting.
Knitting is something to do with my hands while my brain is otherwise occupied. I don't watch a lot of television, but I knit while I'm reading blogs on the computer, I knit while I'm talking to my husband, I even prop a book up in a book holder and knit while I'm reading.
I knit because I love the process, not because I love the product. I've made one sweater in my life, and it's probably the reason I never made another one--it was gorgeous, a tangerine orange sleeveless polo top out of cotton--it turned out too small and I gave it to a friend. The effort put into knitting it made the disappointing outcome all the sharper.
When I was a teenager, I knitted handbags and tote bags out of rug yarn. Then there was a long dry spell, and I recently started knitting again--scarves, tote bags, and socks. I've just started a vest, though, and if it turns out okay, I plan to move back into sweaters, and have accumulated a stash ready to go.
But back to my point. I'm mostly not interested in doing intarsia or fairisle or cables. I may be--probably will be--some day, but for me, right now, I want to knit something simple, just garter stitch or stockinette, something where I can turn off my brain for awhile. I'm not a knitwear designer, although who knows? I may design something one day. Right now I want something that I can pull out of my bag while I'm stuck in traffic, or have a free moment at the office, or in the half hour before I go to bed at night. I don't want something that I have to spend a lot of thought on, I want to be able to just pick it up and knit.
And I have a feeling that's what these actresses want, too: something they can pull out of their bag when they have a free moment or two, knit mindlessly for a little while, then stuff back in the bag when they have to go back to work.
Knitting, even if it's just a garter stitch scarf on big needles, is more than just producing a garment. Producing a beautiful garment is wonderful, of course, but so is a scarf, if knitting it allows you to lose yourself in it for a little while.